Tayyib › Guides › Is lard halal? Which "Schmalz" comes from the pig

Is lard halal? Which "Schmalz" comes from the pig

Lard is not halal, and neither refining nor the quantity changes that. The question that causes trouble on packs is a different one: which "Schmalz" actually comes from the pig, and what does the word "Fett" tell you when no animal is named?

Anyone searching "is lard halal" usually knows the answer already. This page covers what comes next: what Schmalz can be called on a pack, which kinds of Schmalz have nothing to do with the pig, and what EU law requires when a pack says "Fett".

What is lard?

Schweineschmalz is fat from the pig that has been rendered: heat melts it out of the fatty tissue and it is filtered. In the kitchen there are two forms, the white, almost tasteless Schmalz and Griebenschmalz, which has Grieben (fried bacon cubes), onions and often apple stirred in. On ingredient lists and menus it appears as:

  • Schweineschmalz, Schmalz, Griebenschmalz, Schweinefett
  • saindoux (French), lard (English), strutto (Italian), manteca de cerdo (Spanish), domuz yağı (Turkish)
  • شحم الخنزير, دهن الخنزير (Arabic)

The foreign forms are false friends in both directions, as Translating ingredient lists shows: French "lardon" is a cube of bacon, while English "lard" is not meat but the fat.

Why lard is not halal

The Quran forbids pork in three places: 2:173, 5:3 and 6:145. The last one names its flesh explicitly and calls it impure (rijs). The four Sunni schools treat the animal as a whole, its fat included, and do not dispute this. Lard therefore falls under the same rule as pork, and Tayyib reads it as haram, the strongest of its three levels.

Why rendering and refining change nothing

With gelatine, carmine or emulsifiers scholars discuss istihala, transformation: a substance that was forbidden or impure loses the prohibition, on this doctrine, if it changes so far that it has a different name and different properties. Resolution No. 198 (4/21) of the International Islamic Fiqh Academy of the OIC, from 2013, requires a complete chemical change for that. A partial one is not enough.

Lard does not meet this. The fat is melted, filtered, bleached and deodorised, the fat molecules stay the same, and the result is still called Schmalz or "Fett, tierisch". A hardened fat also remains a fat, and the EU only requires the addition "fully hydrogenated" or "partially hydrogenated". That all of this is cleaning and not transformation is our application of the criterion to a case that we do not find as a case of its own in the resolution. The gelatine debate in Is gelatine halal? rests on the same question, except that there collagen really is broken down in a chemical process.

Not every Schmalz is pork

The word "Schmalz" does not always contain a pig. With no animal named in front of it, German means Schweineschmalz by it, and that is how Tayyib reads it. If the ingredient names another animal or a plant, it is judged by that substance:

  • Butterschmalz: clarified butter, that is pure milk fat. Halal, and Tayyib does not flag it.
  • Pflanzenschmalz: baking fat from hardened or mixed vegetable fat, mostly coconut or palm. Halal, and Tayyib does not flag it.
  • Gänseschmalz, Hühnerschmalz, Rinderschmalz (goose, chicken, beef): not pork fat, but fat of animals that are permitted when slaughtered in the Islamic way. The pack does not show that, so Tayyib reads them as doubtful. A halal statement from the manufacturer answers the question, as with any beef product.

Where Schmalz turns up

  • Bread spreads: Griebenschmalz and Schmalz on bread, in a jar or a tub.
  • Sausage and canned meat: liver sausage, bratwurst and canned stews often contain pork and pork fat together.
  • Schmalz pastries: Schmalznudeln, Krapfen and some other pastries are traditionally fried in Schmalz.
  • Ready meals: fried potatoes or red cabbage from a jar can list Schmalz as the frying fat.
  • Bakery, butcher, snack bar: loose goods usually carry no ingredient list. There the only help is to ask what the dough was made with and what was fried.

What the pack has to say

The EU Food Information Regulation (No 1169/2011) sets out in Annex VII, Part A, what fats must be called in the ingredient list. Refined fat of animal origin is called "Fett" there, with the word "tierisch" (animal) or the species added. Refined vegetable fats may be grouped as "pflanzliche Fette" if each plant is then named separately. A pack can therefore legally say "Fett, tierisch" and so keep quiet whether it is beef or pork.

Tayyib reads it like this:

  • Schweinefett, Schweineschmalz, Schmalz and the foreign-language names: haram.
  • Animal fat with no species: doubtful, because the animal stays open.
  • Vegetable fat: not flagged.
  • If only "Fett" or "Speisefett" (edible fat) is written, Tayyib flags nothing. That is not a clearance but the limit of what an ingredient list gives.

A halal statement elsewhere in the ingredient list changes nothing about lard, because pork is forbidden whatever the slaughter. "Ohne Schweineschmalz" (without lard), on the other hand, Tayyib reads as saying what it says.

In short

  • Lard is haram, also rendered, refined or hardened.
  • Istihala does not help, because rendering and refining clean the fat and do not turn it into another substance.
  • Butterschmalz and Pflanzenschmalz are not pork and are not flagged.
  • Goose, chicken and beef Schmalz read doubtful because the slaughter is open.
  • For refined animal fat the EU requires "Fett" with "tierisch" or the species, so "animal fat" leaves the animal open.
  • For loose goods from a bakery or snack bar, ask, because there is no ingredient list.

Frequently asked questions

Is lard halal?

No. Pork is forbidden by the consensus of the four Sunni schools, and the fat belongs to the animal. Tayyib reads Schweineschmalz, Schmalz, Griebenschmalz and Schweinefett as haram, the strongest of its three levels.

Does refined or hardened lard become halal?

No. Rendering, filtering, bleaching and deodorising clean the fat but do not turn it into a different substance. Resolution No. 198 of the International Islamic Fiqh Academy requires a complete chemical change for istihala, and a hardened fat remains a fat.

Is Butterschmalz or vegetable Schmalz halal?

Yes. Butterschmalz is clarified butter, that is milk fat, and Pflanzenschmalz is made of vegetable fat, usually coconut or palm. Neither contains pork, and Tayyib does not flag them.

And goose, chicken or beef Schmalz?

They are not pork fat, but they are fat of animals whose slaughter the pack does not show. Tayyib therefore reads them as doubtful, not haram. A halal statement from the manufacturer answers the question.

Does the pack always say that lard is in it?

On packaged food the EU labelling regulation requires refined animal fat to be named as "Fett" with the addition "tierisch" (animal) or with the species, so a phrase like "animal fat" does keep the animal quiet. Loose goods from a bakery, butcher or snack bar usually have no ingredient list, and there the only help is to ask about the dough and the frying fat.

Next: is gelatine halal? →

Note: this article is not a fatwa and not a certification. Tayyib shows whether an ingredient is flagged, where it typically comes from and why the origin decides it. In case of doubt, the binding assessment rests with the manufacturer or a recognised certification.

Does your pack say Schmalz or "animal fat"? Scan the barcode with Tayyib and see straight away whether it is flagged.